The bench upheld the Intellectual Property High Court’s earlier ruling for KOEI Tecmo to pay CAPCOM 143,843,710 yen (roughly US $1.43 million).
The settlement concludes the lawsuit originally filed in 2014.
So what is this lawsuit originally about?
CAPCOM sued Koei Tecmo for infringing a couple of game-related patents that were owned by the company.
The first patent (patent No.3350773) involved unlocking more content by reading the disc of a previous game, commonly seen in the Xtreme Legends expansions of Dynasty Warriors and Samurai Warriors games.
The other (Patent No.3295771) handled controller rumble to convey information not visible on the player’s screen (such as enemies nearby) and was used in the Fatal Frame series.
The case was filed on July 4, 2014, and the Osaka District Court ruled on December 14, 2017, that KOEI Tecmo infringed on Patent B only, ordering the company to pay 5.17 million yen (about US $48,000) in damages and legal fees.
Further Appeals Filings
However, CAPCOM had been highly dissatisfied with the ruling, so the legal back and forth continued. An appeal was filed with the Intellectual Property High Court on December 27, 2017.
CAPCOM requested damages that totaled 983,231,115 yen (about US $9.12 million) for KOEI Tecmo’s infringement of Patents A and B.
Another ruling in Capcom’s Favor
On September 11, 2019, Japan’s Intellectual Property High Court ruled mostly in CAPCOM’s favor. The court had dismissed some of the first patent’s claims, it upheld all the remaining claims, including the ones for the second patent.
Koei Tecmo was then ordered by the high court to pay 143,843,710 yen in compensation to CAPCOM. Koei Tecmo sent their final appeal to the Supreme Court of Japan on September 24, 2019.
CAPCOM’s aforementioned patents have since expired. In the latest press conference, Koei Tecmo had no choice but to accept the court’s verdict.
The Final Appeal
Madly in love with anime and football...... it's disturbing.